Notable Cases Involving Lip Patterns in Forensic Dentistry

 

     courtesy photo

Lip patterns, or cheiloscopic evidence, have been used in several high-profile forensic cases to identify perpetrators and victims. Here are two cases where lip pattern analysis played a pivotal role in solving crimes involving assassination and abuse.

Case 1: The Coffee Cup Assassin

Location: Eastern Europe, 2017
Crime: Political Assassination

Overview:
A prominent journalist known for investigating political corruption was found dead in his apartment. The crime scene appeared staged to suggest a suicide, but subtle inconsistencies drew the attention of forensic experts. Among the evidence collected was a coffee cup found on the journalist's desk, bearing an incomplete lip impression.

Investigation:
Forensic odontologists used cheiloscopy to analyze the partial lip pattern on the cup. By enhancing the faint grooves using a combination of alternate light sources and digital imaging software, they managed to reconstruct a significant portion of the print. This unique pattern was compared to a database of known associates and persons of interest.

The lip print matched a known political operative suspected of eliminating critics of a high-ranking government official. The operative had visited the journalist under the guise of conducting an interview and had poisoned the coffee during the meeting.

Outcome:
The match provided critical evidence linking the suspect to the crime scene. Coupled with toxicology reports and surveillance footage, the lip pattern analysis solidified the case. The political operative was arrested, tried, and convicted, bringing justice to the victim and exposing the corruption behind the crime.

Case 2: A Mother's Silent Cry

Location: South Asia, 2021
Crime: Domestic Abuse and Murder

Overview:
A young woman was found dead in her home under suspicious circumstances, with her husband claiming it was a tragic accident. However, investigators suspected foul play, as there were bruises and signs of prior abuse. A lipstick-stained tissue discovered in the bathroom became a crucial piece of evidence.

Investigation:
Forensic experts analyzed the lip print on the tissue using Santos’ classification system. The grooves suggested the print belonged to the victim. However, the orientation and placement of the tissue revealed a chilling detail—it had been forcefully pressed against her lips. Further investigation uncovered similar tissues with the victim's lip prints in the trash, indicating a history of silencing her during violent arguments.

The husband’s fingerprints on the tissues corroborated the physical evidence. When confronted with the findings, the suspect admitted to smothering his wife in a fit of rage.

Outcome:
The lip pattern evidence played a pivotal role in demonstrating both the abuse leading up to the murder and the method used to kill the victim. The husband was convicted of murder and sentenced to life imprisonment. The case highlighted the importance of lip prints in documenting abuse and homicide in domestic settings.

Conclusion

These cases underscore the versatility and effectiveness of lip pattern analysis in forensic dentistry. Whether unraveling politically motivated assassinations or exposing domestic violence, cheiloscopy provides a unique avenue for investigators to uncover the truth and deliver justice. As technology advances, the potential applications of this technique in solving crimes continue to expand.